Government Agencies Put Truck Transportation Companies in the Crossfire

By May 15, 2014 June 16th, 2015 Government, Industry News, NationaLease

Hiring drivers that satisfy both the FMCSA and the EEOE is like walking a tightrope…the slightest misstep and down you go.

Don’t you wish that, occasionally, government agencies would talk to one another before they set up rules and regulations? There’s nothing tougher to deal with than trying to satisfy two agencies working at cross purposes. This was illustrated perfectly in two articles that appeared on; one last month, “Carriers Caught Between Conflicting Agencies on Hiring,” and one just last week, “Safety & Compliance: Beware these background screening pitfalls.”


The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) requires companies that hire drivers to do whatever is necessary to avoid hiring high-risk individuals. Obviously, companies want to hire the safest drivers possible, not because a federal agency mandates it, but because it’s just good business. Bad or unsafe drivers can result in substantial liability. But a new initiative of the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) is complicating the issue. They are now going after companies that use criminal background and credit history checks in hiring decisions. For companies that automatically eliminate anyone with a felony record, the EEOC is cracking down and pursuing multi-million dollar settlements.

This falls right into HR’s purview and is just one of the many issues we deal with when hiring for the trucking industry. A company’s reputation depends on many things; however, a good safety record is right up there at the top of the list. So hiring drivers with spotless records is something we hope for. That’s not to say that people who may have made mistakes in their past can’t turn out to be tremendous assets to a company. They can. To make the right decision for the company and yet not run afoul of EEOC rules, make sure a number of factors are used when deciding who to hire:

  • Don’t automatically disqualify an applicant with a previous felony conviction.
  • Be able to prove you’re banning criminal conduct that’s directly related to the job requirements.
  • Have face-to-face interaction with the prospective employee to make an individual, rather than a blanket, decision.
  • Remove checkboxes that ask if the potential hire has ever been convicted of a felony. If you want to keep the question, leave space for an explanation.
  • If you do have the above question, include a disclaimer that indicates that answering “yes” is not an automatic disqualifier.

The most recent article also talks about overall background checks and how, if a candidate is not hired based on the background check, he or she must be given the opportunity to dispute or correct the findings. Especially in an age of identity theft and hacking, people’s credit can be ruined through no fault of their own. Or clerical errors can show a conviction where none occurred. If, after an explanation, you still decide not to hire the person, you must send out a letter explaining why.

All businesses are subject to these rules; however, with the constant turnover in our industry, truck transportation companies are more likely to find themselves dealing with these issues. We all know a prevailing concern in our industry is driver and technician shortage. We want to hire the best people for the job. We just have to always ensure that we’re doing it in the right way.

This shortfall of qualified drivers and technicians is a major issue. So, over the next couple of months, I’ll be publishing a number of posts about hiring practices and tips on how to find the best employees possible.

Image source:

Jane Clark

About Jane Clark

Jane Clark is Vice President of Member Services for NationaLease. Before joining the full service truck leasing organization, she served in executive positions with some of the nation’s top staffing and recruitment agencies.

Leave a Reply